Compare Β· BTC spot ETFs
MSBT vs HODL
Morgan Stanley Bitcoin Trust against VanEck Bitcoin Trust
- HODL is cheaper: 0.00% vs 0.14% a year, or $1.40 less per $1,000 held.
- HODL is 1.4x the size of MSBT by net assets.
Verdict: HODL
HODL is both the cheaper and the larger fund, so it is the default pick unless you need MSBT for a specific brokerage or account.
Fees: what the expense ratio costs you
MSBT charges 0.14% and HODL charges 0.00% a year. On a $10,000 position that is $14 versus $0 per year, taken out of the fund's assets daily rather than billed to you. Over five years the gap compounds to roughly $70 per $10,000 in HODL's favour, before any return.
Size and liquidity
HODL holds about $1.2B against $873M for MSBT. A larger fund usually means tighter bid-ask spreads and more options volume, which matters if you trade around the open rather than hold for years. The five-day flow row shows which fund investors are adding to right now; see the full daily table on the flows page.
Pre-market estimate accuracy
Pre-Tick's pre-market estimate has landed closer to the official open for MSBT (median miss 0.03%) than for HODL (0.06%). Both are re-priced every minute from live Bitcoin on the MSBT and HODL pages, with the method on the accuracy page.
FAQ
- Is MSBT or HODL cheaper?
- HODL, at 0.00% a year versus 0.14% for MSBT.
- Which is bigger, MSBT or HODL?
- HODL, with about $1.2B in net assets against $873M for MSBT.
- Do MSBT and HODL move together?
- Yes. Both hold Bitcoin, so their daily returns are nearly identical before fees. The lasting differences are the expense ratio, fund size and how tightly each trades to its net asset value.
Both funds hold BTC, so their daily moves are nearly identical; the lasting differences are fees, size and liquidity. Estimate miss is how far Pre-Tick's pre-market estimate landed from the official 9:30 AM ET open (see accuracy). Flows are US spot ETF net flows from SoSoValue. Not investment advice.